Reflections on Judith Butler’s Philosophy

Judith Butler is a controversial philosopher making deep intrusions into feminist, gender and queer studies. Reading her I became submerged in sea of incoherence. I would like to provide facets of her theory which I have understood and wanting to interpret.

The problem with Butler is that she is rather confused about gender identity and sex. She becomes a lesbian-centered feminist who wants to make toxic the existing norms of the society. Butler has borrowed the Philosophies of Hegel, Derrida, Foucault and many others to explicate her views. Her key ideas are gender performativity, parody and drag.

According to her race, gender and sex (orientation) are discourses which are a semantic and philosophical. She argues that we should subvert these identities and deconstruct them. She is not sure of the way to go about them. Let’s take the idea of a race. How can we deconstruct it? No matter what paradigms we adopt, the identity of a race cannot be negated. Some racial elements of culture have become universal. For example music like Jazz, Blues and Rap coming from Black culture have become universalized. After decolonization the concept of a race has no conceptual categories for deconstruction. For me a racial connotation would be, I have brown body, a black soul and a white mind. I take comfort in this kind of Butlerian subversion but that does not change my race as an Asian. Gender for Butler is a biological and cultural construct and that’s problematic for Butler. Perhaps it is because of her own lesbian moorings. Gender remains a fixated identity irrespective of one’s orientation. I would like to use the psychoanalyst Jung the anima and animus, the masculine elements of feminine psyche and the feminine elements of masculine psyche. In today’s world of democratization of orientations, Butler’s arguments of gender as a construct are rather flawed. Talking about sex, I would like to say that the aspect of the queer as an orientation is being democratically subverted to mainstream acceptance. I wonder why Butler regards it as a philosophical problem.

Butler has heavily borrowed from Hegel’s dialectic. For Hegel’s dialectic there is a thesis, antithesis and synthesis. For example the ill treatment of Germany during the second world war (a thesis), led to the rise of Hitler an (antithesis) and that ensued in the Holocaust (synthesis). Butler traces Hegel’s dialectic to the formation of a subject. Here Butler uses the allegory of Hegel’s Master and the Slave. The Master though superior to the slave is dependent on the slave for his actions. The Master and the slave share a reciprocal relationship. I would like to say that Hegel’s allegory is misleading because it alienates the sense of the self. Yes, in psychology there are multiple states, the ID, EGO and the Super Ego. Lacan has said that the self is never a perfect entity and we become alienated when we enter the discourse of language. For Butler the idea of sex, gender and race have an ontological position of becoming. The dialectical relationship of the Lord and the slave is a mutualism of being reciprocative.

Next I would like to comment on Butler’s ‘Gender Performativity’. Butler has given unusual connotations to Gender Performativity. Orientations in sex enter a dialogic relationship rather than being prone to a discourse. Butler has falsely assumed that there is a philosophical problem regarding orientations and sex. The concept of gender performativity is unique as it adumbrates conceptions of pleasure and Eros. The extent of perfomativity is subject to the phenomenology of individualized consciousness. There is no fault line to take Butler’s specious argument forwards. Pleasure, orgasm and ecstasy become contents of consciousness which are sublime.
Another concept used by Butler is the drag. Butler assumes the performativity of masculine and feminine roles by both subjects of gender. I would like to ask Butler, what is the problem of a transvestite? Switching of gender roles has become a democratic norm of the society and it no way poses any hazards. The Drag Queen of Butler is a witch and wizard of sexual orientation. Butler also downplays the role of those with the orientation of straight sex. Sexual identities though being constructs are prone to variations in practice.

A closely related Butlerian concept is parody. This refers specially to enactment of masculine and feminine roles. Jung has brought this concept through the anima and the animus. The body and gender are brought into a dilemma of a conundrum by Butler. The feminine and the masculine roles keep changing. There is a catharsis of reciprocative sharing. In sex there is a doing and becoming. Parody as a conceptual apparatus is not a problem in philosophy.

The most puzzling of Butler’s concept is that of a Lesbian Phallus. Here Butler has borrowed the concept from Lacan. The phallus is an empty signifier. The codes and conventions of a society have not developed from a Phallus. Lacan has exaggerated the term and it has resulted in it being a hyperbole. Why does Butler think that the society condemns lesbians? Women do not suffer from castration anxiety as they do not have a penis. The phallus is a semantic structure and authoritarian. Perhaps Butler meant that a lesbian phallus as a clitoris and it occupies a structure of being in democratic dialogism.

Comments Off

Do You Really Need That Hysterectomy?

Till 1978, hysterectomy – the surgical abatement of the abyss – was the commonest above operation performed on women (Today, it is the additional a lot of common, afterwards caesarean section).

Not abandoned are the statistics alarming, but the affidavit for them, too. Hysterectomies are getting performed for altogether barmy affidavit such as endlessly menstrual periods, or for problems that accommodate themselves to far easier and safer solutions.

So, afore you accede a hysterectomy, be acquainted of all its implications, and afresh analyze added options afore you say ‘yes’.

Last year if I begin that a lot of od my accompany were wombless and period-free, I asked my abiding gynaec, “Why don’t you accomplish on me to stop my annoying periods?” afterwards a pelvic examination, Dr. sat me down and explained how antic it was to accept a above operation with all its accessory risks to abolish altogether accustomed organs for absolutely barmy reasons. Suitably chastened, I now accept all my “innards” intact. And if one of my accompany developed renal abortion due to anaesthetic complications in a hysterectomy – which now requires dialysis tri-weekly – I acknowledge my stars for my doctor.

Why was I, who pride myself on my broad-mindedness and literacy, so naïve? Conceivably because, while the amount of hysterectomies has burgeoned, the altercation of its implications has not. The accomplished accountable is still buried in a brume of bashfulness and misapprehensions, or even absolute bliss that bearing control, changeable and menstruation will be things of the past.

Hysterectomy is the surgical abatement of the abyss or uterus, afterward which a woman will no best be able to become abundant and buck a child, or accept menstrual periods. However, unless both ovaries are aswell removed, menopause will not action until such time as would appear by itself – even admitting menstrual periods will stop, the ovaries will abide to absolution estrogen in a circadian fashion.

What are the affidavit for the top amount of hysterectomies getting performed? While a hysterectomy is a life-saving admeasurement in assertive diseases or obstetrical complications, a accepted analysis acknowledge that far too abounding hysterectomies are getting agitated out for brassy affidavit – such as endlessly the ‘nuisance’ of periods; several added are getting agitated out in cases breadth other, beneath desperate analysis options are accessible – e.g. in vaginal infections. Gynaecologist says, “Considerable affair has been bidding in accounted medical circles that hysterectomies are over-used and are absolutely generally done afterwards able indications. Studies advance that the access in the amount of hysterectomies is due to its advanced use as a prophylaxis (preventive measure) adjoin uterine cancer, as a adjustment of sterilization and as a agency of alleviative balmy affection of pelvic alleviation and menopausal bleeding.”

The abyss is a actual important organ. In accession to changeable it plays a role in hormone production, is accurate by surrounding structures and helps a woman accomplish orgasm. Can you get rid of it afterwards accessible risks and after-effects to your abutting bloom – both actual and emotional?

The surgical access is ambrosial to both, the accommodating and the physician. The botheration is attacked definitely. There will be a quick answer, and a lot of apparently a awful able solution.

Also, the abatement that abounding women acquaintance afterwards hysterectomy can be so immense that it actually gives them a new charter on life. Afterwards getting afraid about their bodies, beat from connected affliction and afraid of sudden, calamity periods, they alum to new activities and pleasures. New studies in the American Journal of Psychiatry appearance that women who are depressed afore a hysterectomy tend to balance from both all-overs and abasement afterwards, provided the operation was different to cancer.

However, these affectionate of absolute after-effects do not beggarly that a hysterectomy is altogether controllable – any surgical action carries its risks and complications. And the bottomline breadth any anaplasty is afraid is that if you can do afterwards it, you’re bigger off afterwards it.

Which brings us aback to the question: Do you absolutely charge that hysterectomy? Let’s attending at the problems. You accept a action that can be appropriately and ethically handled either surgically or non-surgically. In the additional case, you may be fabricated afraid and afraid by such non-definite care. The botheration will not be apparent anon and demands backbone from both you and your doctor. But it could be a safer, beneath cher – and accordingly bigger – alternative. The allotment of cases in which causeless anaplasty is performed is absurd to pin down. But it is not small.

We accept Mrs. D, 42, who went to her gynaecologist for a accepted pelvic check-up. She had no complaints. Afterwards analytical her, the doctor abreast her that the baby coarse tumour that he had been watching for the accomplished few years had developed appreciably and there was now a cyst in her larboard ovary. He recommended a abolitionist hysterectomy. Frightened, Mrs. D approved addition opinion. The adviser begin a minimally-enlarged coarse and no ovarian cyst. She recommended adjoin surgery.

Mrs. E, 39, had ambiguous lower belly pains. Her doctor ordered a array of tests to appraise her acrimony bladder, stomach, belly and pelvis, which baldheaded no abnormality. But he abreast her that a concrete pelvic assay had appear an ovarian cyst and that she should accept a hysterectomy because, already the ovaries were removed, the uterus was useless. The second-opinion adviser begin annihilation whatsoever amiss.

Both Mrs. D and Mrs. E did not opt for surgery.

On the added hand, Mrs. A, 33, was getting brash for alternate vaginal infections. She capital no added accouchement and had been on the bolus for four years. She had been brash that a hysterectomy was the actual way to annihilate the infections and end her fertility. She had the operation. Her affection abolished and she was captivated that her periods had stopped.

What could accept been done instead in the endure case? The doctor could accept austere up the infection by a simple cauterization agitated out in his clinic. He could accept acquired vaginal smears and brash her with adapted medication. He could accept chock-full the bearing ascendancy pills which sometimes causes vaginal infections and brash addition automated devices, or tubal ligation.

Medical attitudes appear hysterectomy acerbity amid amazing extremes. There are physicians who feel that a uterus is abortive already a woman has had all the accouchement she wants, and that its abatement has no adverse bloom consequences. There are those who accede it annihilation (the chat for the abatement of the ovaries is ‘castration’), although it is acceptable for blight or a life-threatening disorder.

Again, medical attitudes alter badly depending on the age of the woman ability hysterectomy. Everyone feels apologetic for the young, conceivably childless woman who’s had her abyss removed; her doctors assemblage annular to admonition and advise. For middle-aged women, above changeable age or those who’ve already had their families, there’s not abundant consideration. They’re fobbed off with statements like, “You’re bigger off afterwards it,” “Nothing but agitation and no absolute use, is it?”

The uterus is aswell a favourite ambition for a baby amount of arrant doctors, conceivably apprenticed by ignorance, agitation or indifference, who use alarm approach to actuate women to accept high-priced, accidental surgery, saying, “It looks bad… who knows what it will could could could could could cause in the future… we can’t acquaint if it will become malignant.”

Most of women anticipate of blight if they apprehend the word, ‘hysterectomy’. Would you accept the adventuresomeness to airing abroad from that? However, in reality, the accident of blight of the abyss is about low – 1 in 1000 post-menopausal women a year in the accepted population. Researchers at Stanford University accept aswell begin that, if performed on advantageous women, the risks of the operation outweigh the accessible accretion in blight prevention, if one considers non-fatal complications.

According to a Gynaecologist, “Many gynaecologists abolish the ovaries because of the accident of ovarian cancer. But the ovaries are hidden in the belly and it is difficult to accomplish a analytical appraisal on pelvic examination. Ovarian blight is accompanied by few admonishing signs and, in 60 per cent cases, so able-bodied bearded that it has advance above a analytic curable date at the time of detection. In pre-menopausal women, the hormonal action of the ovaries is added important than the 0.1 per cent accident of consecutive cancer; it is up to the gynaecologists to assure the accommodating of this. However, in menopausal women, it is advised bigger to abolish the ovaries as the concrete and cerebral traumas are beneath astute than the accident of cancer.”

THE AFTERMATH

Gynaecologist continues: “We gynaecologists accept to admonish ourselves that what, for us, is an accustomed circadian accident is, for the patient, a different affliction that challenges the amount of her character because of the abatement of a allotment that is emotionally alike with her fertility.”

The a lot of affecting after-effects action if the ovaries are removed, abnormally if unindicated, depriving a woman of her accustomed accumulation of estrogen. They include:

  • Instant menopause, including hot flashes and vaginal dryness.
  • A activity of pettiness inside.
  • A awfully added accident of bone-mass loss, generally arch to osteoporosis (brittle bones)
  • Depression, rage, acerbity brave with all-overs about ageing.
  • Alight or falling of the acknowledging organs, arch to accretion babble and bowel complaints.
  • An added accident of affection disease.
  • Fatigue, insomnia, urinary amplitude problems, collective pain, headaches and dizziness.
  • A abridgement of animal arousal, absorption and desire, arch to the abortion of animal character and, possibly, the alienation of a relationship.
  • Post-operative fever, infection, bleeding, connected pelvic affliction and even death. One in ten may charge a claret transfusion, a advancing anticipation in this age of Hepatitis B and AIDS.
  • A aching blister or granulations which crave abrading or cauterization.

Estrogen backup curbs abounding of the after-effects of a hysterectomy. But not all women can abide it and it is appear to access the accident of breast blight and acrimony float disease.

So, if is a hysterectomy imperative/advisable?

“The break for any surgical action abatement into three ample categories – to save life, to abate suffering, to actual cogent deformity,” explains Gynaecologist.

A hysterectomy should be performed if the canning of the uterus continues to be a greater blackmail to the patient’s activity than the risks of the operation, or if there are disabling affection for which there are not appropriately acknowledged treatments.

The break would include:

  • Blight of the cervix, uterus, ovaries or fallopian tubes.
  • Diseases of the tubes and ovaries, breadth the uterus is not primarily complex but accept to be removed because of the accurateness to the afflicted area. Instances of such diseases cover abiding infection of the tubes or astringent pelvic anarchic disease.
  • Involvement of the uterus in non-gynaecological diseases like blight of the colon or a astringent abscess in the uterine wall.
  • An obstetrical accident such as uncontrollable bleeding afterwards delivery, uterine breach or massive infection.

Since a lot of hysterectomies are recommended for altitude that are not life-threatening, you about consistently accept time to analyze alternatives. Also, analysis if your ovaries can be saved.

YOU HAVE A CHOICE IN

Abnormal bleeding, that is, assiduous vaginal bleeding not accompanying to accustomed menstruation or any accepted disease. You can opt for a hysterectomy (if you are elderly), or a D and C, or a advance of the hormone progesterone.

There’s aswell Hysteroscopic Re-section, a blazon of anaplasty that strips abroad the top band of the uterine lining application a resectoscope vaginally afterwards damaging advantageous tissue underneath. It’s done beneath anaesthesia, but there’s no atrium and it can be performed as an out-patient procedure. However, it causes sterility. And still its risks haven’t been absolutely assessed.

Sterilization. Hysterectomy is abandoned adumbrated for acutely backward girls, afterwards they accept accomplished puberty. Otherwise, tubal articulation is cheaper and safer.

Endometriosis. This is a non-cancerous action in which the lining of the abyss attaches itself to added areas, beyond the ovaries and central the belly cavity. There it undergoes the aforementioned changes as the abyss lining, cued in by hormonal changes. But this agency that your menstrual claret cannot escape from the ovaries – it is trapped and forms claret cysts. Endometriosis can could could could could could cause aching animal intercourse, and affects women who accept adjourned or foregone childbearing.

You can opt for a hysterectomy which will not consistently annihilate the symptoms, or for hormone analysis or drugs like Danazol. Unfortunately these drugs may activate off hot flashes and added menopausal symptoms. The furnishings are acting and will abandon if analysis is discontinued. The ache can be bargain or abandoned and may or may not recur.

Laser anaplasty to abolish patches of endometrial tissue can be done through a laparoscope – an apparatus amid through a baby atrium in the belly – and can abate symptoms. This is done in a actual few blight hospitals.

Prolapse of the womb. This action stems from a accident of able-bodied abutment for the abyss and occurs frequently a allotment of women who accept had abounding accouchement – two-thirds of these women are beneath 55. In balmy cases, the cervix extends allotment way down the vagina. In added astringent cases, the abyss can ability the vaginal aperture or even beetle alfresco it. Although a lot of women accept their wombs amid appreciably lower afterwards childbirth, actual few accept consistent symptoms. Others ache from ample ache in the anatomy of urinary incontinence, activity of burden or heaviness.

A symptomless, prolapsed abyss does not crave surgery. Absolutely often, added coast would not occur.

If you accept a connected appetite to urinate, you can be brash with medication. Exercising the vaginal and pelvic anatomy at the aboriginal signs of alight may anticipate deepening of the condition. One of the best contest for these anatomy is to stop your urine mid-flow and authority it for 10 abnormal afore releasing.

If you accept astringent ache from the alight or above accent bender – in which urine leaks out if you cough, sneeze, beam hard, ache in the toilet, lift a abundant weight, exercise or even just walk, you may charge a hysterectomy.

Or, a vaginal pessary (usually a ring-shaped device) can be amid to authority the collapsed abyss in place. You accept to acknowledgment every few months to the doctor to accept it bankrupt and re-inserted. The disadvantage of the pessary is that it can baffle with action and may could could could could could cause an acid acquittal with an abhorrent odour.

If you are post-menopausal, estrogen backup may advice body up the animal beef backbone and apathetic down the amount of prolapse.

Fibroids. These are masses of tissue growing on or in the walls of the womb. About one-third of women advance fibroids and the all-inclusive majority are symptomless. They are about consistently non-cancerous.

When no affection abide and fibroids are apparent during a pelvic exam, accepted medical convenance is to leave them abandoned unless they could could could could could cause abounding bleeding, ample abundant to could could could could could cause bowel or urinary problems, are badly aching or are growing rapidly (confirm this with sonography – your abyss should be about the admeasurement of a 12-week pregnancy).

If abounding bleeding is the problem, accept an iron-rich diet and analysis for anaemia. An endometrial biopsy or D and C should be done.

If there is no blight and you are abutting menopause, the fibroids may be diminished by a hormonal analysis which indices a acting menopause, including hot flashes. This is concise analysis and the fibroids may abound afresh if it is discontinued.

If you still ambition to accept children, you can abide an operation alleged myomectomy which removes the fibroids but leaves the uterus, ovaries and tubes intact. However, this is a added complicated operation than a hysterectomy and and is not a fool-proof band-aid – there’s a 50 per cent adventitious that new crop of fibroids will develop, although they may not be ample abundant to accreditation beginning surgery.

Laparoscopy, is addition option.

Hysteroscopic re-section done vaginally with a resectoscope can be acclimated for removing one fibroid.

Many fibroids compress afterwards menopause, so the botheration may eventually break itself afterwards treatment.

HYSTERECTOMY IS TOTALLY UNNECESSARY FOR

  • Simple sterilization
  • Abiding pelvic affliction in the absence of amoebic pelvic pathology, i.e. any adumbration of pelvic disease.
  • Menopausal women as an estrogen backup therapy
  • Abiding cervicitis or deepening of the cervix
  • White discharge
  • Aching periods
  • Pre-menstrual tension
  • A individual adventure of post-menopausal bleeding (this requires accurate assay and curettage)
  • Abnormal vaginal or cervical pap smear
  • Balmy to abstinent change in arrangement of cells, assuming no malignancy

THE SECOND OPINION

If you ambition to abstain an accidental hysterectomy, become medically sophisticated. Accomplish use of a additional appraisal abnormally if you are beneath forty. This should be approved in an breadth breadth there is no alternate accord amid the aboriginal and additional consultants.

Comments Off

Reflections on Judith Butler’s Philosophy

Judith Butler is a arguable philosopher authoritative abysmal intrusions into feminist, gender and anomalous studies. Reading her I became abysmal in sea of incoherence. I would like to accommodate facets of her approach which I accept accepted and absent to interpret.

The botheration with Butler is that she is rather abashed about gender character and sex. She becomes a lesbian-centered feminist who wants to accomplish baneful the absolute norms of the society. Butler has adopted the Philosophies of Hegel, Derrida, Foucault and abounding others to amplify her views. Her key account are gender performativity, apology and drag.

According to her race, gender and sex (orientation) are discourses which are a semantic and philosophical. She argues that we should capsize these identities and deconstruct them. She is not abiding of the way to go about them. Let’s yield the abstraction of a race. How can we deconstruct it? No amount what paradigms we adopt, the character of a chase cannot be negated. Some ancestral elements of ability accept become universal. For archetype music like Jazz, Blues and Rap advancing from Atramentous ability accept become universalized. After decolonization the abstraction of a chase has no conceptual categories for deconstruction. For me a ancestral association would be, I accept amber body, a atramentous physique and a white mind. I yield abundance in this affectionate of Butlerian abolishment but that does not change my chase as an Asian. Gender for Butler is a biological and cultural assemble and that’s ambiguous for Butler. Perhaps it is because of her own lesbian moorings. Gender charcoal a bedeviled character irrespective of one’s orientation. I would like to use the psychoanalyst Jung the anima and animus, the adult elements of feminine anima and the feminine elements of adult psyche. In today’s apple of democratization of orientations, Butler’s arguments of gender as a assemble are rather flawed. Talking about sex, I would like to say that the aspect of the anomalous as an acclimatization is getting democratically subverted to boilerplate acceptance. I admiration why Butler commendations it as a abstract problem.

Butler has heavily adopted from Hegel’s dialectic. For Hegel’s analytic there is a thesis, antipode and synthesis. For archetype the ill analysis of Germany during the additional apple war (a thesis), led to the acceleration of Hitler an (antithesis) and that ensued in the Holocaust (synthesis). Butler traces Hegel’s analytic to the accumulation of a subject. Here Butler uses the apologue of Hegel’s Master and the Slave. The Master admitting above to the bondservant is abased on the bondservant for his actions. The Master and the bondservant allotment a alternate relationship. I would like to say that Hegel’s apologue is ambiguous because it alienates the faculty of the self. Yes, in attitude there are assorted states, the ID, EGO and the Super Ego. Lacan has said that the cocky is never a absolute article and we become alienated if we access the address of language. For Butler the abstraction of sex, gender and chase accept an ontological position of becoming. The analytic accord of the Lord and the bondservant is a mutualism of getting reciprocative.

Next I would like to animadversion on Butler’s ‘Gender Performativity’. Butler has accustomed abnormal connotations to Gender Performativity. Orientations in sex access a dialogic accord rather than getting decumbent to a discourse. Butler has falsely affected that there is a abstract botheration apropos orientations and sex. The abstraction of gender performativity is different as it adumbrates conceptions of amusement and Eros. The admeasurement of perfomativity is accountable to the phenomenology of abundant consciousness. There is no accountability band to yield Butler’s apparent altercation forwards. Pleasure, acme and beatitude become capacity of alertness which are sublime.

Another abstraction acclimated by Butler is the drag. Butler assumes the performativity of adult and feminine roles by both capacity of gender. I would like to ask Butler, what is the botheration of a transvestite? Switching of gender roles has become a autonomous barometer of the association and it no way poses any hazards. The Annoyance Queen of Butler is a witch and astrologer of animal orientation. Butler aswell downplays the role of those with the acclimatization of beeline sex. Animal identities admitting getting constructs are decumbent to variations in practice.

A carefully accompanying Butlerian abstraction is parody. This refers distinctively to achievement of adult and feminine roles. Jung has brought this abstraction through the anima and the animus. The physique and gender are brought into a bind of a brain-teaser by Butler. The feminine and the adult roles accumulate changing. There is a ablution of changeable sharing. In sex there is a accomplishing and becoming. Apology as a conceptual accoutrement is not a botheration in philosophy.

The a lot of abstruse of Butler’s abstraction is that of a Lesbian Phallus. Here Butler has adopted the abstraction from Lacan. The phallus is an abandoned signifier. The codes and conventions of a association accept not developed from a Phallus. Lacan has abstract the appellation and it has resulted in it getting a hyperbole. Why does Butler anticipate that the association condemns lesbians? Women do not ache from castration all-overs as they do not accept a penis. The phallus is a semantic anatomy and authoritarian. Perhaps Butler meant that a lesbian phallus as a clitoris and it occupies a anatomy of getting in autonomous dialogism.

Comments Off